Frequently Asked Questions

How to shop online

My Catholic Gifts makes your shopping experience easy and simple. Our amazing online search helps you navigate through the many products to find the perfect gift for a loved one or friend. You can also restrict your search by price, category, most popular, newest, special offers and so much more! Once you find the product you are looking for, simply choose the options (if applicable), select the quantity and add it to the cart. From there all you need to is proceed with the checkout and once that is processed, your order will be on its way!


Do we offer free shipping?

Yes, we offer free shipping if you place an order over 50.00. You can read more about our shipping policy here.


Do we accept Paypal?

Yes, we do accept Paypal. You will see it as a payment option during checkout.


What credit cards do we accept?

We accept the following credit cards: Visa, MasterCard, American Express, JCB, Discover, and Diners Club.


Do we accept checks or cash?

Unfortunately, we do not accept checks or cash at this time. Payments can be made via credit card or Paypal only. 


Do we ship internationally?

Unfortunately, we are not shipping internationally at this time.


How do I return my order?

Return are very simple with My Catholic Gifts. Simply log into your account, find the order you wish to return, and go through the return process. You can read more about the return process here.


Can I call in an order over the phone?

Yes, you can call our Customer Care team and place an order with one of team members over the phone. Our Customer Care number is 740-481-0449.